Skip to main content

#97 in NYC

OhBoy

Williamsburg, Brooklyn

5.1/10
#97 NYC · AVERAGE
The OhBoy Burger at OhBoy

Brotherly Breakdown

Written by Brotherly Burgers

Oh Boy's burger is let down by its meat. The patty was very underwhelming, which is the one thing a smashburger this simple cannot afford.

The sauce was solid. That is the only element we would credit, and it is not enough.

Best for

Casual smashburgers in Williamsburg.

The catch

The meat was very underwhelming.

What it's actually like

Oh Boy is a Williamsburg café and burger counter on Havemeyer Street, built around smashed burgers, breakfast, and music.

Our record of this burger is two observations, so this is going to be short. The patty was very underwhelming. On a stripped-down smashburger the patty is most of what there is, and a failure there is not something a sauce or a topping can recover.

The sauce was solid. That is a genuine positive and it is the only one we wrote down.

We would rather tell you our notes on this one are two lines long than pad them into something that reads more complete than it is. We cannot tell you about the crust, the bun, the cheese, or why the meat fell short, because we did not record any of it.

Why this score

On a burger this simple the patty carries the whole thing, and ours was very underwhelming.

A solid sauce is not enough to offset that, and nothing else in our record argues for a better result.

Last written July 2026.

Neighborhood
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Cuisine
Burger Joint
Price
$

Oh Boy Burger

5.1/10
#97 NYC · AVERAGE

Burger from OhBoy.

$15