← All neighborhoods
Best Burgers in Midtown
The short answer
- Best burger in Midtown
- GUI8.1 · #42 citywide
Scored by Brotherly Burgers. Updated July 2026.
Midtown finally has real burger depth. GUI (8.1) currently tops the neighborhood, ahead of Legasea (7.8) and Le Rock (7.7). Harry Cipriani (7.4) delivers a solid burger from an iconic Italian institution and Handcraft Burgers (7.0) covers the fast-casual end. The Polo Bar (6.5) and Monkey Bar (5.8) prove that a famous room doesn't guarantee a great patty. With dozens of steakhouses and hotel restaurants in the area, we still expect more from Midtown — and we have 15+ restaurants on our radar here.
- Restaurants
- 21
- Burgers ranked
- 7
- Avg score
- 7.2
Burger rankings in Midtown
All burger restaurants in Midtown
Harry Cipriani
Italian, $$$$, 1 ranked7.4/10
GOOD
Monkey Bar
American, $$$$, 1 ranked5.8/10
AVERAGE
The Polo Bar
American, $$$$, 1 ranked6.5/10
SOLID
Legasea
Seafood, $$$, 1 ranked7.8/10
GOOD
Handcraft Burgers and Brew
Burger Joint, $$, 1 ranked7.0/10
GOOD
GUI
Steakhouse, $$, 1 ranked8.1/10
STANDOUT
Le Rock
French Brasserie, $$$, 1 ranked7.7/10
GOOD
Burger Joint
Burger Joint, $Black Iron Burger
Burger Joint, $$Burgers & Brew
Burger Joint, $$Dynamo Room
American, $$$Gallagher's
Steakhouse, $$$$Greywind
American, $$$Keene's
Steakhouse, $$$$Lovely's Old Fashioned
Diner, $$The Plaza Hotel
American, $$$$Zou Zou's
Mediterranean, $$$PJ Clarkes
Pub, $$Black Tap
American, $$Ted's Montana Grill
American, $$Wollensky's Grill
Steakhouse, $$$