← All neighborhoods
Best Burgers in Red Hook
The short answer
- Best burger in Red Hook
- Red Hook Tavern9.9 · #1 citywide · Dry Aged
Scored by Brotherly Burgers. Updated July 2026.
Red Hook is home to the #1 burger in New York City. Red Hook Tavern's dry-aged patty scored a 9.9, the highest rating we've ever given, and it earned its Pantheon status on every bite. This is a destination burger in a destination neighborhood; you're going out of your way to get here, and it's worth every minute of the trip. If you eat one burger in NYC, make it this one.
- Restaurants
- 2
- Burgers ranked
- 1
- Avg score
- 9.9
