Skip to main content
← All neighborhoods

Brooklyn

Best Burgers in Williamsburg

The short answer

Best burger in Williamsburg
Diner8.4 · #33 citywide

Scored by Brotherly Burgers. Updated September 2026.

Williamsburg has 4 ranked burgers and a surprisingly deep roster. Diner (8.4) leads with a seasonal patty in a 1927 dining car that changes with the market and rewards repeat visits. Emmy Squared (7.3, now closed at its Williamsburg original) brought Detroit-style energy to a more casual setting. Peter Luger (5.2) and OhBoy (5.1) round out the lower end, with Peter Luger proving that a legendary steakhouse reputation does not automatically translate to burgers.

Restaurants
10
Burgers ranked
4
Avg score
6.5

Burger rankings in Williamsburg

The Grass-Fed & Finished Burger at Diner
Diner
Williamsburg
8.4/10
STANDOUT
Emmy SquaredClosed
Williamsburg
7.3/10
GOOD
The Luger-Burger at Peter Luger
Peter Luger
Williamsburg · Dry Aged
5.2/10
AVERAGE
The OhBoy Burger at OhBoy
OhBoy
Williamsburg
5.1/10
AVERAGE

All burger restaurants in Williamsburg

Diner
New American, $$$, 1 ranked
8.4/10
STANDOUT
Emmy Squared
Pizza & Burgers, $$, 1 ranked
7.3/10
GOOD
Peter Luger
Steakhouse, $$$$, 1 ranked
5.2/10
AVERAGE
OhBoy
Burger Joint, $, 1 ranked
5.1/10
AVERAGE
The Bedford
American, $$$
On our list
Frita Batidos
Cuban, $$
On our list
The Commodore
Southern, $$
On our list
St Anselm
Steakhouse, $$$
On our list
Sol Et Soleil
French, $$
On our list
Namkeen
Pakistani, $
On our list